What the poll shows
Friday, July 30th, 2010There’s still a day to go before the end of the first My Last Song poll. It asks what type of music you want played at your funeral and the choices are between hymns, modern secular, classical secular, classical religious, a mix of those and something else.
I’m not going to give away the numbers who polled, but I’m intrigued by the four per cent who went for something else. I don’t think they were wanting the classic Cannonball Adderley Blue Note jazz album Somethin’ Else, which highlighted a young Miles Davis. Possibly poetry or readings, or even silence.
More interesting though is how few people – 18 per cent at the time of writing – wanted hymns.
People coming across My Last Song, or accepting my invite to vote in the poll, are likely to be interested in their personal choice of music and unless they are strong Christians, this won’t include Hymns.
Of the ten or so funerals I’ve attended, about half were traditional and featured hymns. They had the benefit of encouraging all the mourners to join in, which meant we felt we shared the same emotions as we knew the melodies or were happy to follow the choir.
But those ceremonies where secular music was chosen were far more interesting as the officiant gave a brief description of why the song was chosen and it helped bring back memories or know something new about the person to whom we were saying goodbye. Mourners continued to discuss the songs at the reception and, forgive the horrible term, they added more value to the send off than the traditional hymns which, while giving everyone the opportunity to have a good sing, were forgotten as soon as the last note on the organ stilled into silence.
Anyway, in the My Last Song poll, secular modern songs scored well over twice the votes of hymns, and are followed by the sensible compromise of a mix of secular and classic.
If in the next 36 hours, lots of devout Christians enter the poll and there’s a surge in support for hymns, then so be it, but I think that’s unlikely. So, if an early ‘exit poll’ is to be believed, secular songs are considerably more popular as choices for farewell music.
Strange then that hymns are sung at so many funerals that take place even in today’s secular society.
I will be considering the reasons for this in my next blog. It will be next week so don’t hold your breath in anticipation.

